Affliate Disclaimer: When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Swipe Previous
Swipe Next
Lionel - Butterfinger Reefer (6-9858) Items for Sale
First Catalog: Lionel 1974 O27 Catalog
Most Recent Catalog: Lionel 1976 O/O27 Catalog
Part Number: 6-9858
We have a new model train website, Find My MTH Trains, to help you find MTH Train items.
| eBay Summary - Currency Code: USD | Count | Avg. Price (USD) | Low Price (USD) | High Price (USD) |
| Bid Auctions | 1 | 16.00 | 16.00 | 16.00 |
| Buy it Now Auctions | 40 | 28.53 | 5.00 | 215.00 |
Listed below are current active eBay auctions for this Item.
Click on the image or link to see more details about the auction on eBay.
41 Open
Current eBay Auctions
Title: Lionel 691MM81137 MEMORY MODULE / SD70MAC / BNSF #9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.00
Item location: Flowery Branch, US
Seller Rating: 695168/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.00
Item location: Flowery Branch, US
Seller Rating: 695168/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Trains NICE! BUTTERFINGER CANDY BAR BILLBOARD REEFER BOXCAR 6-9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.95
Item location: Cuyahoga Falls, US
Seller Rating: 6364/99.2%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.95
Item location: Cuyahoga Falls, US
Seller Rating: 6364/99.2%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL PART - 9858 MPC BUTTERFINGER REEFER BODY -W/DOORS - NEW- W14
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.99
Item location: Morganville, US
Seller Rating: 112748/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.99
Item location: Morganville, US
Seller Rating: 112748/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Vintage 6-9858 LIONEL BUTTERFINGER BILLBOARD box car mid 1970s model train
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $12.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Johnson City, US
Seller Rating: 1/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $12.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Johnson City, US
Seller Rating: 1/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: BUTTERFINGER CANDY BAR REEFER # 858 REPL/BOX LIONEL 6-9858 CURTISS
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $13.59
Item location: Deer Park, US
Seller Rating: 2777/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $13.59
Item location: Deer Park, US
Seller Rating: 2777/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Vintage Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Box Car 6-9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $14.50 or Best Offer
Item location: Reading, US
Seller Rating: 197/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $14.50 or Best Offer
Item location: Reading, US
Seller Rating: 197/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL 9858 - O Gauge - BUTTERFINGER Candy Reefer Boxcar - Orange & Blue - Nice!
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $14.95 or Best Offer
Item location: Lemont, US
Seller Rating: 1325/99.4%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $14.95 or Best Offer
Item location: Lemont, US
Seller Rating: 1325/99.4%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Lines O Scale Curtiss Butterfinger NADX 9858 Shell 9.5" Long
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $15.00
Item location: Tooele, US
Seller Rating: 5283/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $15.00
Item location: Tooele, US
Seller Rating: 5283/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: o scale Lionel Butterfinger billboard refrigerator boxcar #9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $15.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Sharpsville, US
Seller Rating: 754/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $15.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Sharpsville, US
Seller Rating: 754/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Vintage Lionel Butterfinger Billboard Refer 9858 With Original Box
Currency: USD
Current Bid Price: $16.00 ( 0 bids) or Best Offer
Auction Ends: 2nd October, 2025
Item location: Newark, US
Seller Rating: 2437/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Current Bid Price: $16.00 ( 0 bids) or Best Offer
Auction Ends: 2nd October, 2025
Item location: Newark, US
Seller Rating: 2437/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel #6-9858 Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Original Box C-7
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $17.99
Item location: Garden City, US
Seller Rating: 60760/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $17.99
Item location: Garden City, US
Seller Rating: 60760/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL #9858 BUTTERFINGER BOX CAR
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Saint Helen, US
Seller Rating: 5825/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Saint Helen, US
Seller Rating: 5825/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Trains 6-9858 NADX Curtiss Butterfinger Woodside Reefer Boxed see ad
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.00
Item location: North Tonawanda, US
Seller Rating: 16239/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.00
Item location: North Tonawanda, US
Seller Rating: 16239/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel #6-9858, O Ga. Butterfinger Box Car. W/box, See Ad. (14G)
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.35
Item location: North Tonawanda, US
Seller Rating: 16239/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.35
Item location: North Tonawanda, US
Seller Rating: 16239/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Trains, O Gauge, Curtiss Butterfingers Candy Woodside Reefer 6-9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.95 or Best Offer
Item location: Upper Falls, US
Seller Rating: 5706/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.95 or Best Offer
Item location: Upper Falls, US
Seller Rating: 5706/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Vintage 1973 LIONEL 6-9858 Curtiss BUTTERFINGER Billboard Reefer Car in O/O-27
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $20.95
Item location: Miami, US
Seller Rating: 901/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $20.95
Item location: Miami, US
Seller Rating: 901/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Collectible Train MIB
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $20.95
Item location: Brooklyn, US
Seller Rating: 34770/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $20.95
Item location: Brooklyn, US
Seller Rating: 34770/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: CURTISS BUTTERFINGER 9858 LIONEL 027 FREIGHT CAR. 10". GREAT CONDITION WITH BOX
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Norfolk, US
Seller Rating: 28/0.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Norfolk, US
Seller Rating: 28/0.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: VINTAGE 6-9858 LIONEL BUTTERFINGER BILLBOARD Box car mid 1970s Original Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.15 or Best Offer
Item location: Joppa, US
Seller Rating: 1186/99.6%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.15 or Best Offer
Item location: Joppa, US
Seller Rating: 1186/99.6%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Trains 6-9858 NADX Curtiss Butterfinger Reefer Boxed
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Merrillville, US
Seller Rating: 727/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Merrillville, US
Seller Rating: 727/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger And 6-9860 Gold Medal Reefer
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Modesto, US
Seller Rating: 319/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Modesto, US
Seller Rating: 319/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL: 9858 BUTTERFINGER BILLBOARD REFEER C-8 LN WORN ORIGINAL BOX
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $23.00
Item location: Merrillville, US
Seller Rating: 4516/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $23.00
Item location: Merrillville, US
Seller Rating: 4516/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: NIB, Lionel 9858, Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Car
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $24.99
Item location: , US
Seller Rating: 3853/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $24.99
Item location: , US
Seller Rating: 3853/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL BUTTERFINGER CURTISS CANDY “BILLBOARD” REEFER 6-9858! O GAUGE WOODSIDE
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $24.99
Item location: Donegal, US
Seller Rating: 19351/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $24.99
Item location: Donegal, US
Seller Rating: 19351/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Car No Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $25.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Angola, US
Seller Rating: 1151/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $25.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Angola, US
Seller Rating: 1151/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: 1973 LIONEL 9858 BUTTERFINGER REFRIGERATED BILLBOARD REEFER BOXCAR O GAUGE C-8+
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $25.00
Item location: Cherry Hill, US
Seller Rating: 7216/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $25.00
Item location: Cherry Hill, US
Seller Rating: 7216/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL BUTTERFINGERS CANDY BILLBOARD REEFER 6-9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $26.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Mentor, US
Seller Rating: 3549/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $26.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Mentor, US
Seller Rating: 3549/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL #9858 BUTTERFINGER REEFER - 1973-76 - NO BOX
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $26.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Adrian, US
Seller Rating: 114/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $26.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Adrian, US
Seller Rating: 114/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: 1973 Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger Reefer NIB L4024
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $27.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Ann Arbor, US
Seller Rating: 31419/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $27.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Ann Arbor, US
Seller Rating: 31419/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Car (O-gauge 3-rail-2 conductor)
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Columbia, US
Seller Rating: 3823/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Columbia, US
Seller Rating: 3823/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL BOX CAR # 9858 - BUTTERFINGER 0-027
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.00
Item location: Shippensburg, US
Seller Rating: 25812/98.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.00
Item location: Shippensburg, US
Seller Rating: 25812/98.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Vintage 1973 Lionel 6-9858 Curtiss Butterfinger Billboard Reefer General Mills
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99
Item location: Bensalem, US
Seller Rating: 17356/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99
Item location: Bensalem, US
Seller Rating: 17356/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Vintage Lionel Butterfinger Billboard Reefer 6-9858 Train Car Boxed General Mill
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99 or Best Offer
Item location: North Andover, US
Seller Rating: 1242/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99 or Best Offer
Item location: North Andover, US
Seller Rating: 1242/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger Box Car O Gauge WHI-29
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99
Item location: Utica, US
Seller Rating: 14163/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99
Item location: Utica, US
Seller Rating: 14163/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Trains 6-9858 Butterfinger Billboard ReeferCar
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Bristol, US
Seller Rating: 614/98.1%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Bristol, US
Seller Rating: 614/98.1%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
41 Open
Back to the top
Last Updated September 29, 2025, 6:45 am America/New_York
Copyright © 2025 N. & C. Stevens
Privacy Policy
➤