Affliate Disclaimer: When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Swipe Previous
Swipe Next
Lionel - Butterfinger Reefer (6-9858) Items for Sale
First Catalog: Lionel 1974 O27 Catalog
Most Recent Catalog: Lionel 1976 O/O27 Catalog
Part Number: 6-9858
We have a new model train website, Find My MTH Trains, to help you find MTH Train items.
| eBay Summary - Currency Code: USD | Count | Avg. Price (USD) | Low Price (USD) | High Price (USD) |
| Bid Auctions | 0 | |||
| Buy it Now Auctions | 29 | 30.10 | 5.00 | 215.00 |
Listed below are current active eBay auctions for this Item.
Click on the image or link to see more details about the auction on eBay.
Current eBay Auctions
Title: Lionel 691MM81137 MEMORY MODULE / SD70MAC / BNSF #9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.00
Item location: Flowery Branch, US
Seller Rating: 716125/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $5.00
Item location: Flowery Branch, US
Seller Rating: 716125/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel O Gauge 6-9858 Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Car in Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.00
Item location: Taunton, US
Seller Rating: 4836/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.00
Item location: Taunton, US
Seller Rating: 4836/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Vintage Lionel O Guage Butterfinger Refrigerator Box Car NADX 9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.97
Item location: Saratoga Springs, US
Seller Rating: 83/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $11.97
Item location: Saratoga Springs, US
Seller Rating: 83/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Butterfinger Woodside Reefer 6-9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $13.99
Item location: West Orange, US
Seller Rating: 4190/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $13.99
Item location: West Orange, US
Seller Rating: 4190/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL PART - 9858 MPC BUTTERFINGER REEFER BODY -W/DOORS - NEW- W14
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $14.99
Item location: Morganville, US
Seller Rating: 113728/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $14.99
Item location: Morganville, US
Seller Rating: 113728/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Lines O Scale Curtiss Butterfinger NADX 9858 Shell 9.5" Long
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $15.00
Item location: Tooele, US
Seller Rating: 5382/99.6%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $15.00
Item location: Tooele, US
Seller Rating: 5382/99.6%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 9858 Butterfinger Billboard Reefer BNIB
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $15.00 or Best Offer
Item location: West Farmington, US
Seller Rating: 2865/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $15.00 or Best Offer
Item location: West Farmington, US
Seller Rating: 2865/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: o scale Lionel Butterfinger billboard refrigerator boxcar #9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $15.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Sharpsville, US
Seller Rating: 876/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $15.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Sharpsville, US
Seller Rating: 876/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 O Gauge Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Car LN/Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $18.19
Item location: Flowery Branch, US
Seller Rating: 716055/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $18.19
Item location: Flowery Branch, US
Seller Rating: 716055/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Trains 6-9858 NADX Curtiss Butterfinger Woodside Reefer Boxed see ad
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.00
Item location: North Tonawanda, US
Seller Rating: 16718/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.00
Item location: North Tonawanda, US
Seller Rating: 16718/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel #6-9858 Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Original Box C-7
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.99
Item location: Garden City, US
Seller Rating: 62383/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $19.99
Item location: Garden City, US
Seller Rating: 62383/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Vintage 1973 Lionel 6-9858 Curtiss Butterfinger Billboard Reefer General Mills
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.50
Item location: Bensalem, US
Seller Rating: 17993/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.50
Item location: Bensalem, US
Seller Rating: 17993/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger And 6-9860 Gold Medal Reefer
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Modesto, US
Seller Rating: 334/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $22.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Modesto, US
Seller Rating: 334/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL: 9858 BUTTERFINGER BILLBOARD REFEER C-8 LN WORN ORIGINAL BOX
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $23.00
Item location: Merrillville, US
Seller Rating: 4528/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $23.00
Item location: Merrillville, US
Seller Rating: 4528/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: VINTAGE 6-9858 LIONEL BUTTERFINGER BILLBOARD Box car mid 1970s Original Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $24.50 or Best Offer
Item location: Joppa, US
Seller Rating: 1402/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $24.50 or Best Offer
Item location: Joppa, US
Seller Rating: 1402/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL BUTTERFINGER CURTISS CANDY “BILLBOARD” REEFER 6-9858! O GAUGE WOODSIDE
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $24.99
Item location: Donegal, US
Seller Rating: 20665/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $24.99
Item location: Donegal, US
Seller Rating: 20665/99.8%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Car No Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $25.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Angola, US
Seller Rating: 1160/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $25.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Angola, US
Seller Rating: 1160/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Vintage Lionel Butterfinger Billboard Reefer 6-9858 Train Car Boxed General Mill
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $25.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Las Vegas, US
Seller Rating: 9/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $25.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Las Vegas, US
Seller Rating: 9/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: BUTTERFINGER CANDY BAR REEFER # 858 REPL/BOX LIONEL 6-9858 CURTISS
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $26.87
Item location: Deer Park, US
Seller Rating: 2841/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $26.87
Item location: Deer Park, US
Seller Rating: 2841/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL #9858 BUTTERFINGER REEFER - 1973-76 - NO BOX
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $26.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Adrian, US
Seller Rating: 148/99.2%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $26.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Adrian, US
Seller Rating: 148/99.2%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Car (O-gauge 3-rail-2 conductor)
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Columbia, US
Seller Rating: 3938/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Columbia, US
Seller Rating: 3938/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL BOX CAR # 9858 - BUTTERFINGER 0-027
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.00
Item location: Shippensburg, US
Seller Rating: 26002/99.4%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.00
Item location: Shippensburg, US
Seller Rating: 26002/99.4%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Vintage 1978 Lionel Butterfinger Refer Car O O27 Gauge Original Box NOS #6-9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.00
Item location: Dyer, US
Seller Rating: 683/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.00
Item location: Dyer, US
Seller Rating: 683/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger Box Car O Gauge WHI-29
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99
Item location: Utica, US
Seller Rating: 14963/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99
Item location: Utica, US
Seller Rating: 14963/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: LIONEL Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Car Item 9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99
Item location: Las Vegas, US
Seller Rating: 2641/99.1%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $29.99
Item location: Las Vegas, US
Seller Rating: 2641/99.1%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: VINTAGE 6-9858 LIONEL BUTTERFINGER BILLBOARD REEFER, 1973/74-76, NEW
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $30.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Morrisville, US
Seller Rating: 913/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $30.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Morrisville, US
Seller Rating: 913/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 6-9858 Butterfinger Reefer Car NIB
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $39.99
Item location: Manorville, US
Seller Rating: 12323/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $39.99
Item location: Manorville, US
Seller Rating: 12323/99.9%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel Butterfinger Billboard Reefer Car #9858 Mint W/Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $59.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Forked River, US
Seller Rating: 522/97.2%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $59.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Forked River, US
Seller Rating: 522/97.2%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Title: Lionel 81137-2 BNSF Legacy Scale SD70MAC Diesel Locomotive Body Shell #9858
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $215.00
Item location: Flowery Branch, US
Seller Rating: 716125/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $215.00
Item location: Flowery Branch, US
Seller Rating: 716125/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Back to the top
Back to the top
Last Updated December 17, 2025, 6:48 am
Copyright © 2025 N. & C. Stevens
Privacy Policy
➤